docs(agents): clarify rule scope and remove permission templates

This commit is contained in:
Ryan Yin
2026-09-05 13:34:13 +08:00
parent 3f74be246c
commit 33b17baeff
4 changed files with 61 additions and 565 deletions
+53 -198
View File
@@ -1,212 +1,67 @@
# AGENTS.md - Guidelines for AI Coding Agents
# Repository Agent Guide
This file defines the default operating guide for AI agents working in this Nix Flake repository.
Keep changes minimal, verifiable, and safe for multi-host deployments.
This flake manages NixOS hosts, macOS via nix-darwin, shared Home Manager profiles, and Colmena
deployments. Keep repository guidance here; reusable global rules live in `agents/AGENTS.md`. See
[agents/README.md](./agents/README.md) for their scope and symlink installation targets.
## Scope and Repository Model
## Where Changes Belong
This repository manages:
- `flake.nix` defines inputs; `outputs/default.nix` composes outputs for `x86_64-linux`,
`aarch64-linux`, and `aarch64-darwin`.
- `modules/` contains system modules; `home/` contains Home Manager modules. Put shared behavior
here rather than duplicating it in host configurations.
- `hosts/` contains host-specific configuration; `outputs/<system>/src/` wires hosts into outputs.
- `vars/` and `lib/` provide shared values and helpers. Use `myvars` and existing abstractions
instead of hardcoding usernames or paths.
- `secrets/` contains agenix definitions; secret material also comes from a private external repo.
- NixOS hosts (desktop + servers)
- macOS hosts via nix-darwin
- Home Manager profiles shared across platforms
- Remote deployments via colmena
## Commands and Platforms
High-level layout:
- Prefer recipes in [Justfile](./Justfile); use `just --list` to discover available commands and
`just --show <recipe>` to inspect behavior before running them.
- The Justfile uses Nushell. Preserve `[linux]` / `[macos]` guards and host naming conventions.
- `just local` uses `nixos-switch` on Linux and `darwin-build` / `darwin-switch` on macOS; their
arguments differ. Check both platforms when changing shared behavior.
- `nix develop` provides formatters and linters. If needed, `nix shell nixpkgs#just nixpkgs#nushell`
provides the task runner and its shell.
```text
.
├── flake.nix # Flake entry; outputs composed in ./outputs
├── Justfile # Primary command entrypoint (uses nushell)
├── outputs/
│ ├── default.nix
│ ├── x86_64-linux/
│ ├── aarch64-linux/
│ └── aarch64-darwin/
├── modules/ # NixOS + darwin modules
├── home/ # Home Manager modules
├── hosts/ # Host-specific config
├── vars/ # Shared variables
├── lib/ # Helper functions
├── agents/ # Reusable cross-project agent files and installer
└── secrets/ # Agenix secret definitions
```
## Validation
## Ground Rules for Agents
- For Nix changes, run `just fmt` and inspect the diff: it formats all Nix files. Nix style is
`nixfmt` with width 100.
- For supported non-Nix files, use `prettier --write <file>` and `prettier --check <file>`;
configuration lives in `.prettierrc.yaml`. Spelling checks use `typos` and `.typos.toml`.
- Run `just test` for configuration changes. It evaluates `.#evalTests` across Linux and Darwin; the
output must be `true`. Exit code zero with `false` is a failed suite.
- Eval tests are `expr.nix` / `expected.nix` pairs under `outputs/<system>/tests/`. Update focused
cases when changing behavior covered by those tests.
- Use `nix flake check` for broader flake checks. A host build can validate changes beyond eval:
`nix build .#nixosConfigurations.<host>.config.system.build.toplevel`.
- Documentation-only changes need formatting checks and `git diff --check`; Nix tests may be
skipped. Report checks run, skipped, or blocked, including the command and reason for failures.
- Prefer `just` tasks over ad-hoc commands when an equivalent task exists.
- Make the smallest reasonable change; avoid drive-by refactors.
- Do not commit secrets, generated credentials, or private keys.
- Preserve platform guards (`[linux]`, `[macos]`) and host naming conventions.
- Run formatting and evaluation checks for touched areas before finishing.
## Nix Conventions
## Quick Start Workflow (Recommended)
1. Inspect context:
```bash
just --list
rg -n "<symbol-or-option>" modules home hosts outputs
```
2. Implement the change.
3. Format:
```bash
just fmt
```
4. Validate:
```bash
just test
```
5. If deployment behavior changed, provide the exact `just` command the user should run (do not run
remote deploys unless explicitly requested).
## Canonical Commands
### Core quality loop
```bash
just fmt # format Nix files
just test # run eval tests: nix eval .#evalTests ...
nix flake check # run flake checks + pre-commit style checks
```
### Dependency/input updates
```bash
just up # update all inputs and commit lock file
just upp <input> # update one input and commit lock file
just up-nix # update nixpkgs-related inputs
```
### Local deploy commands
```bash
just local # Linux: switch config for current hostname
just local boot # Linux: set the next boot config without switching
just local switch debug # Linux: switch with detailed output
just local boot debug # Linux: boot mode with detailed output
just niri # Linux: switch "<hostname>-niri"
just niri boot # Linux: set "<hostname>-niri" for the next boot
just niri switch debug # Linux: switch niri config with detailed output
just local debug # macOS: switch with detailed output
```
### Remote deploy commands (colmena)
```bash
just col <tag> # switch nodes matching tag
just col <tag> boot # set matching nodes' next boot configuration
just lab # switch all kubevirt nodes
just lab boot # set all kubevirt nodes for the next boot
just k3s-prod # switch k3s production nodes
just k3s-prod boot # set k3s production nodes for the next boot
just k3s-test # switch k3s test nodes
just k3s-test boot # set k3s test nodes for the next boot
```
### Useful direct commands
```bash
nix eval .#evalTests --show-trace --print-build-logs --verbose
nix build .#nixosConfigurations.<host>.config.system.build.toplevel
nixos-rebuild switch --flake .#<hostname>
```
## Test Structure and Expectations
Eval tests live under:
- `outputs/x86_64-linux/tests/`
- `outputs/aarch64-linux/tests/`
- `outputs/aarch64-darwin/tests/`
Typical test pair:
- `expr.nix`
- `expected.nix`
Agent expectations:
- If logic changes affect shared modules, run `just test`.
- If only docs/comments changed, tests may be skipped, but say so explicitly.
- If tests cannot run, report why and include the exact failing command.
## Formatting and Style
### Formatting tools
- Nix: `nixfmt` (RFC style, width 100)
- Non-Nix: `prettier` (see `.prettierrc.yaml`)
- Spelling: `typos` (see `.typos.toml`)
### Nix style conventions
- Files use `kebab-case.nix`.
- Prefer `inherit (...)` for attribute imports.
- Prefer `lib.mkIf`, `lib.optional`, `lib.optionals` for conditional config.
- Use `kebab-case.nix` filenames and `inherit (...)` for attribute imports.
- Prefer `lib.mkIf`, `lib.optional`, and `lib.optionals` for conditional configuration.
- Use `lib.mkDefault` for defaults and `lib.mkForce` only when necessary.
- Keep module options documented with `description`.
- Give module options a `description` and preserve platform-specific conditions.
Module pattern:
## Command Hazards
```nix
{ lib, config, ... }:
{
options.myFeature = {
enable = lib.mkEnableOption "my feature";
};
- `just up`, `just upp`, and `just up-nix` use `--commit-lock-file`. When a commit is not
authorized, use `nix flake update <input>` for a scoped input update without committing.
- Deployment and upload recipes change systems; use eval/build commands for validation. Remote
deployment requires an explicit request. When deployment behavior changes, report the exact `just`
command to run.
- `just clean`, `just gc`, `just ggc`, and `just game` remove history or amend commits; they are not
validation steps and require explicit authorization for their target and scope.
- Do not use `just penvof` for process inspection: it can expose secret values.
config = lib.mkIf config.myFeature.enable {
# ...
};
}
```
## Further Context
## Platform Notes
- `Justfile` uses `nu` (`set shell := ["nu", "-c"]`).
- Some tasks exist only on Linux or macOS via `[linux]` / `[macos]` guards.
- `just local` has different implementations per platform:
- Linux: `nixos-switch`
- macOS: `darwin-build` + `darwin-switch`
## Secrets and Safety
- Secrets are managed with agenix and an external private secrets repo.
- Never inline secret values in Nix files, tests, or docs.
- Do not run broad remote deploy commands unless requested.
- Prefer build/eval validation first, deploy second.
## Change Review Checklist (for agents)
Before finishing, verify:
1. Change is scoped to requested behavior.
2. `just fmt` applied (or not needed, stated explicitly).
3. `just test` run for config changes (or limitation explained).
4. No secrets or machine-specific artifacts added.
5. User-facing summary includes what changed and what was validated.
## Common Pitfalls
- Editing host-specific files when the change belongs in shared module layers (`modules/` or
`home/`).
- Forgetting to update both Linux and darwin paths when touching shared abstractions.
- Running deployment commands to validate syntax when `nix eval`/`nix build` would be safer.
- Introducing hardcoded usernames/paths instead of using `myvars` and existing abstractions.
## References
- [README.md](./README.md)
- [agents/README.md](./agents/README.md)
- [Justfile](./Justfile)
- [outputs/README.md](./outputs/README.md)
- [hosts/README.md](./hosts/README.md)
- [home/README.md](./home/README.md)
- [modules/README.md](./modules/README.md)
- [secrets/README.md](./secrets/README.md)
- [Repository overview](./README.md)
- [Outputs and tests](./outputs/README.md)
- [Hosts](./hosts/README.md), [system modules](./modules/README.md), and
[Home Manager](./home/README.md)
- [Secrets](./secrets/README.md)
+8 -2
View File
@@ -9,7 +9,6 @@ The primary workflow is to symlink files from here into each agent runtime/confi
- `AGENTS.md`: global baseline rules for coding agents.
- `evals/global-rules.md`: behavioral scenarios for validating changes to the global rules.
- `permissions.md`: permission policies for agent tool access.
- `install-rules.py`: installs the baseline by creating symlinks in supported agent config dirs.
- `install-cli.md`: curated CLI install/update command snippets.
- `install-skills.md`: curated `npx skills` command snippets.
@@ -17,7 +16,7 @@ The primary workflow is to symlink files from here into each agent runtime/confi
## Core workflow
1. Maintain shared rules in `agents/AGENTS.md`.
2. Define permission policies in `agents/permissions.md`.
2. Configure permissions directly in the agent runtime; auto-approval is generally used.
3. Run `install-rules.py` to refresh symlinks in local agent homes.
4. Use `install-cli.md` and `install-skills.md` as reference snippets when needed.
@@ -42,6 +41,13 @@ Behavior:
- Missing destination directories are skipped.
- Existing destination file/symlink is replaced with a symlink to this repo source file.
The installer links only `AGENTS.md`; it does not install permission configuration, skills, or CLIs.
The repository-root `AGENTS.md` contains guidance for this Nix configuration repository. It is not
the global rules source and is not installed by this script.
Auto-approval controls tool prompting. The global rules still define task authorization, safety, and
secret handling.
## About `install-cli.md` and `install-skills.md`
Use them as snippet libraries:
-175
View File
@@ -1,175 +0,0 @@
{
"$schema": "https://opencode.ai/config.json",
"permission": {
"read": {
"*": "allow",
"*.env": "deny",
"*.env.*": "deny",
"*.env.example": "allow",
"*.pem": "deny",
"*.key": "deny",
"*kubeconfig*": "deny",
".ssh/**": "deny",
".aws/**": "deny",
".kube/**": "deny",
".gnupg/**": "deny"
},
"edit": "allow",
"glob": "allow",
"grep": "allow",
"task": "allow",
"lsp": "allow",
"skill": "allow",
"question": "allow",
"todowrite": "allow",
"webfetch": "allow",
"websearch": "allow",
"external_directory": "ask",
"doom_loop": "deny",
"bash": {
"*": "ask",
"git status *": "allow",
"git diff *": "allow",
"git log *": "allow",
"git show *": "allow",
"git branch *": "allow",
"git remote *": "allow",
"git tag *": "allow",
"git blame *": "allow",
"git reflog *": "allow",
"git stash list *": "allow",
"git lfs *": "allow",
"kubectl get *": "allow",
"kubectl describe *": "allow",
"kubectl logs *": "allow",
"kubectl top *": "allow",
"kubectl api-*": "allow",
"kubectl config *": "allow",
"kubectl explain *": "allow",
"kubectl kustomize *": "allow",
"kustomize *": "allow",
"terraform plan *": "allow",
"terraform show *": "allow",
"terraform state *": "allow",
"terraform output *": "allow",
"terraform version *": "allow",
"terraform providers *": "allow",
"terraform fmt *": "allow",
"gh repo view *": "allow",
"gh repo list *": "allow",
"gh issue view *": "allow",
"gh issue list *": "allow",
"gh pr view *": "allow",
"gh pr list *": "allow",
"gh pr diff *": "allow",
"gh pr checks *": "allow",
"gh api *": "allow",
"gh search *": "allow",
"gh gist list *": "allow",
"gh gist view *": "allow",
"gh release view *": "allow",
"gh release list *": "allow",
"gh workflow list *": "allow",
"gh workflow view *": "allow",
"gh run list *": "allow",
"gh run view *": "allow",
"gh status *": "allow",
"gh auth status *": "allow",
"helm list *": "allow",
"helm get *": "allow",
"helm show *": "allow",
"helm search *": "allow",
"helm repo *": "allow",
"helm status *": "allow",
"helm version *": "allow",
"helm template *": "allow",
"gcloud * list *": "allow",
"gcloud * describe *": "allow",
"gcloud * get-iam-policy *": "allow",
"gcloud config *": "allow",
"gcloud auth *": "allow",
"gcloud version *": "allow",
"nix eval *": "allow",
"nix build *": "allow",
"nix flake *": "allow",
"nix profile *": "allow",
"nix store *": "allow",
"nix search *": "allow",
"nix doctor *": "allow",
"nixos-rebuild build *": "allow",
"darwin-rebuild build *": "allow",
"nom build *": "allow",
"just --list *": "allow",
"just --show *": "allow",
"just --dry-run *": "allow",
"statix check *": "allow",
"deadnix *": "allow",
"nixfmt *": "allow",
"shellcheck *": "allow",
"hadolint *": "allow",
"actionlint *": "allow",
"ruff check *": "allow",
"clippy *": "allow",
"prettier --check *": "allow",
"tokei *": "allow",
"systemctl status *": "allow",
"systemctl list-*": "allow",
"systemctl show *": "allow",
"journalctl *": "allow",
"lspci *": "allow",
"lsusb *": "allow",
"lsblk *": "allow",
"df *": "allow",
"free *": "allow",
"uptime *": "allow",
"uname *": "allow",
"sensors *": "allow",
"lsof *": "allow",
"go version *": "allow",
"go env *": "allow",
"go list *": "allow",
"go doc *": "allow",
"go vet *": "allow",
"cargo --version *": "allow",
"cargo tree *": "allow",
"cargo metadata *": "allow",
"python3 --version *": "allow",
"python3 -m py_compile *": "allow",
"node --version *": "allow",
"pnpm list *": "allow",
"uv pip list *": "allow",
"rg *": "allow",
"fd *": "allow",
"cp *": "allow",
"mv *": "allow",
"chmod *": "allow",
"ls *": "allow",
"cat *": "allow",
"head *": "allow",
"tail *": "allow",
"wc *": "allow",
"find *": "allow",
"which *": "allow",
"echo *": "allow",
"pwd *": "allow",
"date *": "allow",
"env *": "allow",
"printenv *": "allow",
"file *": "allow",
"stat *": "allow",
"du *": "allow",
"tree *": "allow",
"bat *": "allow",
"eza *": "allow",
"jq *": "allow",
"yq *": "allow",
"tldr *": "allow",
"mkdir *": "allow",
"rmdir *": "allow",
"grep *": "allow",
"rm *": "ask",
"rm -rf *": "ask",
"sudo *": "deny"
}
}
}
-190
View File
@@ -1,190 +0,0 @@
# Permissions Configuration
This document records the current permission requirements for AI agents operating in this
repository.
## Scope
| Environment | Policy |
| ------------------------ | ------------------------------------------- |
| **Personal workstation** | Restrictive - protect user's daily workflow |
| **Homelab VMs** | Permissive - agents have full autonomy |
The permissions below apply to **personal workstation** only. For homelab VMs, almost everything is
allowed except destructive operations on production systems.
## Default Policy
| Tool | Permission |
| ---------------- | ---------- |
| `*` (all others) | ask |
## File Read Permissions
| Pattern | Permission |
| --------------- | ---------- |
| `*` (all files) | allow |
| `*.env` | deny |
| `*.env.*` | deny |
| `*.env.example` | allow |
| `*.pem` | deny |
| `*.key` | deny |
| `*kubeconfig*` | deny |
| `.ssh/**` | deny |
| `.aws/**` | deny |
| `.kube/**` | deny |
| `.gnupg/**` | deny |
## Always Allowed Tools
These tools run without prompting:
- `glob`
- `grep`
- `lsp`
- `question`
- `skill`
- `todowrite`
- `webfetch`
- `websearch`
- `codesearch`
- `edit` (covers `write` and `apply_patch`)
## Bash Command Permissions
### Always Allowed (Read-only operations)
**Git:**
- `git status`, `git diff`, `git log`, `git show`, `git branch`, `git remote`
**Kubernetes:**
- `kubectl get`, `kubectl describe`, `kubectl logs`, `kubectl top`
- `kubectl api-resources`, `kubectl api-versions`
- `kubectl config view`, `kubectl config get-contexts`
- `kubectl explain`
- `kubectl kustomize`, `kustomize build`, `kustomize version`
**Terraform:**
- `terraform plan`, `terraform show`, `terraform state list`, `terraform state show`
- `terraform output`, `terraform version`, `terraform providers`, `terraform fmt`
**GitHub CLI:**
- `gh repo view/list`, `gh issue view/list`, `gh pr view/list/diff/checks`
- `gh api`, `gh search`, `gh gist list/view`
- `gh release view/list`, `gh workflow list/view`, `gh run list/view`
- `gh status`, `gh auth status`
**Helm:**
- `helm list`, `helm get`, `helm show`, `helm search`
- `helm repo list`, `helm status`, `helm version`, `helm template`
**Google Cloud:**
- `gcloud * list`, `gcloud * describe`, `gcloud * get-iam-policy`
- `gcloud config list`, `gcloud auth list`, `gcloud version`
**Nix:**
- `nix eval`, `nix build`, `nix flake show`, `nix flake metadata`
- `nix flake check`, `nix flake lock`
- `nix profile list`, `nix profile history`
- `nix store verify`, `nix store ls`, `nix store path-info`
- `nix search`, `nix doctor`, `nix --version`
- `nixos-rebuild build`, `darwin-rebuild build`
- `nom build`
**Just:**
- `just --list`, `just --show`, `just --dry-run`
**Linters & Formatters:**
- `statix check`, `deadnix`, `nixfmt --check`
- `shellcheck`, `hadolint`, `actionlint`
- `ruff check`, `clippy`, `prettier --check`
- `tokei`
**System diagnostics:**
- `systemctl status`, `systemctl list-units`, `systemctl show`
- `journalctl -u`, `journalctl --since`
- `lspci`, `lsusb`, `lsblk`, `df`, `free`, `uptime`, `uname -a`
- `sensors`, `lsof`
**Git (extended):**
- `git tag`, `git blame`, `git reflog`, `git stash list`
- `git lfs status`, `git lfs ls-files`
**Development tools:**
- `go version`, `go env`, `go list`, `go doc`, `go vet`
- `cargo --version`, `cargo tree`, `cargo metadata`
- `python3 --version`, `python3 -m py_compile`
- `node --version`, `pnpm list`, `uv pip list`
**General utilities:**
- `rg`, `fd`, `cp`, `mv`, `chmod`
- `ls`, `cat`, `head`, `tail`, `wc`, `find`, `which`
- `echo`, `pwd`, `date`, `env`, `printenv`
- `file`, `stat`, `du`, `tree`, `bat`, `eza`
- `jq`, `yq`, `tldr`
- `mkdir`, `rmdir`, `grep`
### Requires Confirmation
| Command | Permission |
| ---------- | ---------- |
| `rm *` | ask |
| `rm -rf *` | ask |
### Always Denied
| Command | Permission |
| -------- | ---------- |
| `sudo *` | deny |
## Homelab VM Permissions
For agents running in dedicated homelab VMs, permissions are significantly relaxed:
| Category | Permission |
| -------------------- | --------------------- |
| `bash` | allow (most commands) |
| `edit` | allow |
| `write` | allow |
| `task` | allow |
| `external_directory` | allow |
| `rm` | allow |
**Still restricted in homelab VMs:**
- Production cluster destructive operations (`kubectl delete`, `helm uninstall`)
- Infrastructure teardown (`terraform destroy`)
- Secret exposure in logs
## Other Tool Permissions
| Tool | Permission |
| -------------------- | ---------- |
| `edit` | allow |
| `task` | ask |
| `external_directory` | ask |
| `doom_loop` | deny |
## Summary
- **Default policy**: All tools `ask` — only explicitly whitelisted tools auto-allow
- **File operations**: `read`, `glob`, `grep`, `edit`, `write` all allowed in workspace
- **Nix operations**: Build/eval/flake commands auto-allowed (writes to store only)
- **Linting & formatting**: All check commands auto-allowed
- **System diagnostics**: Read-only system info auto-allowed
- **Sensitive files**: Credentials, keys, and cloud configs are blocked
- **Bash commands**: Read-only ops auto-allowed; `rm` requires confirmation; `sudo` blocked
- **Scope control**: `task` and `external_directory` require approval