Candidate for the Windows e2e gate: the Windows Backend switches and lock order (wip-u-kfw) with the macOS registry and Window methods (wip-u-kfm). Merge of two independent stacks that both touch crates/komorebi-backend; conflicts, if any, are resolved in this revision.
docs/dev/backend-switch.md now has the table of what is switched (focus,
set_rect with top = false, frame reads, plain hide/restore, minimize,
close, raise, maximize), what is left in the Windows crate on purpose
(top = true set_position, the *_with_border calls, transition and ghost
machinery, set_opacity: border and animation subsystems are platform-owned,
seam.md rule 5), and, for each query not switched (foreground_window,
cursor_pos, monitors, window, monitor_from_point), what the trait would
need so step 9 can decide.
Docs only.
process_command (close and minimize of the foreground window, four raise
calls) and monitor_reconciliator (four minimize calls) now call
backend().close/minimize/raise. WindowsBackend runs Window::close,
minimize and raise unchanged (minimize still leaves komorebi-bar alone).
docs/dev/backend-switch.md now holds the full table of what is switched
and what is left, including why the queries (window_rect,
foreground_window, cursor_pos, monitors) were NOT switched: each would drop
an error that callers use or report, or fabricate a default.
BEHAVIOUR: a dead window is skipped by an IsWindow check first; minimize
results are ignored as before. e2e gate needed: commands, monitor
reconciliation (monitor_reconciliator), lifecycle. Verified: Windows clippy
-D warnings via tools/fast-check PASS; e2e not run.
Switch the 40 Window::focus(mouse_follows)? call sites in process_event,
process_command, workspace, window_manager, focus_manager and the
stackbar click to backend().focus(WindowId::from_hwnd(..), mouse_follows).
WindowsBackend::focus runs Window::focus, so the deferral while a window
slides in, the already-foreground shortcut and the cursor centring are
unchanged. animation/transition.rs:534 stays on Window::focus (it is the
code Window::focus defers to). docs/dev/backend-switch.md records what is
switched.
BEHAVIOUR: a dead window now fails early with Error::WindowGone (before:
the Win32 error from raise_and_focus_window) and a failed focus of a window
that died meanwhile reports WindowGone; every caller uses ? or ignores the
result. e2e gate needed: commands, focus, focus_follows_mouse, stacking,
workspaces, lifecycle. Verified: Windows clippy -D warnings via
tools/fast-check PASS; e2e not run.
Adds the three BEHAVIOUR-relevant registry revisions (registration and
forgetting, native-tab sync) with what to look for on a Mac, the mechanical
ones to section B, and a status entry in the bug list saying what of step
11(ii) is done and what is deliberately not (animator lanes, borders,
reaper/live-resize timeouts, the model holding bare ids).
Verified: documentation only.
Lists what must be checked on a Mac once the unified binaries exist: every
macOS revision that changes runtime behaviour (the rule-list lock order,
the shared command listener, pause filter, subscriber push, EventChannel,
SocketMessage, animation prefix, StaticConfig, komorebic launcher, bar-core
hooks and library bumps), the mechanical Step 6/11(i) revisions of this
stack, the walk-through the plan names (focus, move, stack, workspaces,
scrolling, pan, borders, animations, display change, sleep and wake), and
the bugs noticed: the main-queue/WM-lock deadlock of seam.md 3.3, cmd.exe
and explorer.exe in the macOS bar, the update widget's wrong repo, the raw
AX sites that remain outside Window.
Nothing in it was run: macOS cannot be built or tested on this host.
Verified: documentation only.
Appends section 9 to docs/dev/seam.md: for each method of the shared Backend, what WindowsBackend and MacosBackend do and where that differs from what the daemon calls today (windows() and macOS's registry cannot be written faithfully; set_rect on Windows drops the top flag and keeps animation and guards; hide/restore results are ignored on Windows; macOS hide needs a corner and a display; raise on macOS also focuses; macOS monitors() has to be a main-thread-refreshed cache; set_opacity on Windows is the plain write). Concludes that the trait did not have to change and records three proposals (rect as Option, hide's hidden inputs, windows() as start-up operation).
Verified: docs only, not built. Every claim is by reading the code while writing the adapters; what could not be settled by reading is marked 'not verified' in the text.
Adds section 7 (the seven consequences of plan step 7, each with its supporting citations and a status: CONFIRMED, CORRECTED or TARGET; plus three findings the plan did not list: a batch/transaction scope, the workspace methods that exist only on KDE, and error-type differences) and section 8 (everything not confirmed, with how to confirm it on a Mac, a Windows guest or by reading). Verified against the citations of sections 2 to 6 on wip-main aa52fdc4d9e5. Not verified: see section 8.
Adds section 6: event sources per platform and how they reach the window manager (references the step 5 prep entries rather than redoing them) and the evidence for the 'set_rect returns once requested, the frame is observed later' contract: KDE queued commands with an optimistic table write, macOS arrival.rs, settle.rs and animator verification, Windows live_resize settling. Verified against wip-main aa52fdc4d9e5: K/kwin/mod.rs, K/kwin/state.rs, K/window_manager_event_listener.rs, K/backend/mod.rs, M/arrival.rs, M/settle.rs, M/animation/animator.rs, M/window.rs, M/window_manager_event_listener.rs, W/winevent_listener.rs, W/windows_callbacks.rs, W/live_resize.rs. Not verified: any runtime ordering of events.
Adds sections 4 (identity: id types per platform, what acting on a macOS window from a bare id would need, where each tree keeps per-window platform data, HWND width including an observation of 440 distinct HWNDs from the Windows guest logs) and 5 (coordinates: Rect convention, origin and y direction, DPI and scale handling, shadow and frame compensation, and where each conversion lives). Closes two plan items: Windows HWND width and macOS Retina points versus pixels. Verified against wip-main aa52fdc4d9e5: komorebi-layouts/src/rect.rs, W/window.rs, W/windows_api.rs, W/lib.rs, K/kwin/state.rs, K/kwin/bridge.js, M/window.rs, M/application.rs, M/macos_api.rs, M/core_graphics/mod.rs, M/core/rect_ext.rs, M/border_manager/border.rs, M/animation/ghost.rs, M/animation/capture.rs, and ~/e2e-w0 logs read-only for the HWND range. Not verified: HWND width as a Microsoft guarantee, AX values on scaled-resolution or mixed-DPI displays, negative monitor origins on Windows.
Adds section 3.3: the macOS main thread (AppKit and CFRunLoop loop, what runs there), every other thread with its locks, every DispatchQueue::main exec_sync/exec_async/blocking-channel site with file:line and whether the main-side closure takes the window-manager lock, and a precise statement of the possible event-thread/main-thread deadlock, marked by reading, not reproduced. Verified against wip-main aa52fdc4d9e5: M/main.rs, M/macos_api.rs, M/monitor_reconciliator.rs, M/border_manager/{mod,border,ns_window}.rs, M/animation/{animator,ghost}.rs, M/process_event.rs, M/process_command.rs, M/reaper.rs, M/settle.rs, M/workspace_reconciliator.rs, M/window.rs, M/application.rs, dispatch2-0.3.1/src/queue.rs. Not verified: that NSWorkspace and CG display callbacks arrive on main (Apple behaviour), that CFRunLoopAddSource from a non-main thread is safe, that AXUIElement is thread-safe (the code asserts Send+Sync), and the deadlock itself (needs a Mac).
Adds sections 3.1 (KDE) and 3.2 (Windows): every thread that exists, what it locks, and which threads call the platform API. Closes two items the plan listed as unverified: which threads call backend() in KDE (traced: main at start-up and stop, the event thread, command threads, the monitor reconciliator and its settle thread, and tests through with_backend; never the KWin bridge or the hotkey threads) and which threads call WindowsApi, with the thread-affine subset. Verified against wip-main aa52fdc4d9e5: K/main.rs, K/kwin/mod.rs, K/kwin/hotkeys.rs, K/process_event.rs, K/process_command.rs, K/monitor_reconciliator.rs, K/backend/mod.rs, W/main.rs, W/winevent_listener.rs, W/windows_callbacks.rs, W/border_manager, W/stackbar_manager, W/animation, W/live_resize.rs, W/reaper.rs. Not verified: Microsoft's documented behaviour of WINEVENT_OUTOFCONTEXT and cross-thread SetWindowPos, and every Windows call chain (the table lists thread entry points and the API each reaches, not every path).
Adds section 2: the operation table (one row per operation present on at least two platforms: KDE Backend method | Windows | macOS | semantic differences), the platform-subsystem table, and the re-measured counts with the exact method. Verified against wip-main aa52fdc4d9e5: K/backend/mod.rs, K/kwin/mod.rs, W/windows_api.rs, W/window.rs, M/macos_api.rs, M/window.rs, M/core_graphics/mod.rs, M/lib.rs. Not verified: how each AX call behaves against real applications (needs a Mac), and the counts are of source text, not of executed calls.
Creates docs/dev/seam.md with sections 1 (purpose and how to read) and the corrections list. Verified against wip-main aa52fdc4d9e5 by reading K/backend/mod.rs, K/kwin/mod.rs, K/kwin/state.rs, M/macos_api.rs, M/window.rs, M/arrival.rs, M/process_event.rs, M/process_command.rs, W/windows_api.rs. Counts quoted here are measured in the next revision. Not verified: any runtime behaviour (the document is reading-only).
LGUG2Z